Wednesday, January 03, 2024

Goodbye to Texas?

 


There’s a song called, “Leavin’ Old Texas.” The cowboy/singer laments that they’ve roped and fenced the cattle range, “and the people there are all so strange.” Well, it’s true—the open range is fenced, the mythic days of the cowboy are gone, and some of the people in Texas are purely strange now.

But when a writer friend posted on Facebook that she didn’t understand why anyone would live in Texas and not leave, let alone move there, I jumped to our state’s defense. Possibly she was referring to the strict abortion restrictions, so much in the news with the Kate Cox case recently. Or maybe she meant the absence of gun control—no training, no screening, no license. Want to carry a concealed gun? Be our guest. Or perhaps it’s the troubles at the border with record number of illegal immigrants last month. Maybe it’s the restrictions on what can be taught in classrooms, from kindergarten through college—don’t even think of mentioning DEI, which is now outlawed. (How you can outlaw an abstract concept is beyond me, but Gov. Greg Abbott has managed it.) Maybe she meant book bans—we lead the nation in the number of titles marked for “consideration” or actually banned. There are many reasons to leave Texas for states, even countries, where there is more personal freedom and you are not forced to accept the state doctrine. (Does that echo of Nazi days? The state doctrine? Yes, it does).

I haven’t seen statistics on how many people leave Texas because of our extreme right-wing politics, but I know from personal experience—friends who have thrown their hands up in the air and said, “I’m through. I’m leaving.” Often they are couples of child-bearing age. And new corporations? Again, I don’t know statistics, but I have heard of companies that refuse to relocate here—despite our attractive tax laws and other incentives—because employees with families would not follow along.

I credit Texas’ disastrous reputation to Governor Greg Abbott, Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, and Attorney General Ken Paxton. I’m not sure what fascination these men hold for Texans, except perhaps the habit of voting Republican and a blind, inbred of fear of Democrats that makes it hard to pull any lever, mark any ballot except the red one. Why would you ever vote for a man who puts razor wire in a river to injure and kill people? Or who sent poorly dressed, hungry migrants by bus across the country to a northern city where no provisions have been made for their unannounced arrival? If you live in a small town or rural area, why vote for a man who desperately wants to close the school that is the center of your community? It makes no sense.

But I digress. When I read that post, angry as I am at our state government, I immediately felt defensive, compelled to leap to the defense of Texas. I am not a native Texan, but I have lived here almost sixty years, and my two careers—as an author and as a publisher—have relied heavily on the history and literataure of this state. I feel invested in it, and I’ll be darned if a mean little man like Abbott is going to ruin Texas for me and my family.

There’s so much to treasure about our state, politics aside. We have, I suspect, the most varied landscape in the 50 states. In Texas, you can go from beach to mountains, from the stark, spare country of South Texas to the lush high plains. We have forests and pastures and rolling hills and vast expanses of empty land. Texans value their history—okay, we now pretty much agree much of the Alamo legend is in large part myth, but there’s still valuable history in the basic story. And in Sam Houston’s Runaway Scape and defeat of Santa Anna’s troops at San Jacinto. There’s history in the early cattle drives and the gradual shift from an agrarian to an urban economy in too much of the state. We have a proud and strong literary tradition, with writers who chronicled Texas history and wrote their own versions of it, from J. Frank Dobie and his pals to Larry McMurtry, Cormac McCarthy, and Elmer Kelton. Women writers too—Sarah Bird and Sandra Cisneros come to mind. Dr. Ron Tyler has given us several books documenting important artists of our state. Texas food, once mocked as brown food, can compete with upscale servings across the country. We have James Beard award-winning chefs and upscale restaurants with offerings for the sophisticated palate. We also have Tex-Mex, chili, barbecue, and down-home food.

Enough singing the praises of the state I love. My point is Texas is too wonderful to abandon to the narrow minds of right-wing politics. I am not leaving. Greg Abbott was not always governor and will not always be. I will stay to fight his inhumane policies, joining such groups as Mothers Against Greg Abbot, the Texas Democratic Party, and Beto O’Rourke’s Power to the People and speaking out whenever I feel the need. Texas needs to regain its proud reputation, and I want to help. How about you?                               

 

8 comments:

Len Leatherwood said...

I'm with you, sister! I love Texas and also love our home there. However, the politics in California is much more to my liking so I prefer my "dual stateship." I am a native Texan and will fight for the beauty of the state and the kindness of most of its people, Greg Abbott and his cronies not included. I left when Ann Richards was governor and never expected to see this far-right shift. The pendulum will swing soon enough. That is my hope, at least.

Judy Alter said...

California politics are much more to my liking too, Len, but Texas has been good to me. I's given me four children (my adopted babies now grown) and two careers, a whole host of friends, and a really good life. I can't leave now if I wanted to--too dependent, too old to start over--but i don't want to. I want to fight for the Texas I knew and loved.

Next time you come, maybe you can drop by Fort Worth?

Anonymous said...

Great essay! Thank you for this. I am a native Texan and there is a lot to love about this state. But I’ve lived in Colorado and NYC too. I moved back with my family more than 20 years ago. And now, I hope to leave. I’ve had enough! My kids are no longer here and refuse to return. My brother-in-law and wife just left. I want to fight but I’m no longer willing to spend my retirement years here because of the politics, the greed, the traffic and the lack of foresight on the part of so many in power. I figure it will take about 20-30 more years before things turn around. So No, I’m not waiting for that to happen. I can fight from afar. A lot also depends on what happens in the 2024 election. That could definitely push me and my husband, and many friends, to leave - Texas, and maybe the US for a while. I am tired of defending this home state, embarrassed by what it’s become and disgusted by what the 3 “Assketteers” are doing! Oh, did I mention the climate and water problems…?

Judy Alter said...

Thanks for writing. I share a lot of emotions with you, especially embarrassment and disgust. Were I younger and more adventuresome, I'd move to Scotland--a bit of my heart is always in the Highlands. But I am too old to start over and three of my four children are in Texas, if not in Fort Worth. And I have a strong circle of friends. For me, the advantages of staying far outweigh the temptation to leave, but I am still angry. I agree the 2024 election is crucial. Hope you'll join me in speaking out.

Cinder Blog said...

As you know, Judy, I wanted to move to Oregon. It was a long held dream and the politics of that state are better, but still mixed. The rural areas all over the country are pretty much RED, it's just that Texas has the largest rural population in the nation. I hate to color people with a broad brush because there are always exceptions, of course, but that knee-jerk vote for Republicans you mentioned is mostly due to racism. I have lived for the last 30+ years in rural Texas and I can attest to it. They don't think they're racists but a lot of them are, and they consider the Democratic Party to be the party of minorities. I cannot tell you how many times people where I have lived ASSUME I vote Republican simply because I'm an older white woman. And they often say the most racist things to me based on that assumption. The main thing they worry about is not abortion, not school issues, not book bans, not even the fact that their small town are dying because of Republican policies, they get excited over the border. They hate all the minorities coming across in droves. They hate Joe Biden because they blame him for the border crisis even though it's been in crisis for all of my adult life. And they don't realize or care to listen that it is the fault of Congress, particularly Republicans in Congress, that we have this ongoing crisis because it's just too good of a campaign issue for them to do anything to fix it. The county I moved from this year voted 80% for Trump in 2020. They love him because of the Muslim ban, because of the separation of families at the border. They loved those policies. He made it OK for them to be racists, openly racist. And they love Greg Abbott and Ken Paxton for the same reason. Ditto Ted Cruz. It just kills my soul to hear about all the terrible laws this state has enacted since that bunch has been in office. But I don't see it changing, unfortunately. Not as long as we have such a large rural population who want to drag Texas back to the 1950s.

Judy Alter said...

Thanks, Cindy. It's a grim but honest evaluation. We need to educate the rural public in Texas--yesterday! How to make them see truth is a puzzle. Beto couldn't do it before; let's hope he has more success this time around with his Power to the People movement.

Anonymous said...

My sister and brother-in-law left because of the politics. They're not far, though--New Mexico.

Judy Alter said...

Politically, New Mexico is a whole different world. Nice, though, that they're still close, and it's such a lovely place to visit.